User avatar
By ImminentArrival
#63446
I read a comment of someone saying: “You are upon falsehood, what is your proof that Abdullah Hashem was previously incarnated as Yusuf a.s. or Idris a.s. or or or” and he was demanding a solid proof for that.

I want to ask some questions to the ones who make such comments:

O you who doubt, what made you believe Imam Ali a.s. when he said that he a.s. is the first Adam and the first Noah?

According to how you think, I want to ask you what is your proof for the following sayings of Imam Ali a.s. when he said:
“I am the Best Names of Allah which the people have been commanded to make Dua’ with.
I am that Light from which guidance was taken.
I am the owner of The Trumpet.
I am the one who brings out the ones in the graves.
I am the owner of the Day of Resurrection.
I am the companion of Noah and I am the one who rescued him.
I am the companion of Ayoub (Prophet Job) the afflicted, and I am the one who cured him.
I am the one who established/rose the Heavens by the command of my Lord.
I am the companion of Abraham…”

Also, what is the proof which Imam Ali a.s. gave to you when he a.s. said that he is the one who talked to Moses a.s? Even though the Qur’an says that Moses a.s. talked to Allah?

We and you have believed every word Imam Ali a.s. said, even though he did not give us a proof which proves those sayings of his. So the reason we believed him a.s. is because his Imamate a.s has been proven to us and to you, and therefore we submit and believe in everything he a.s. says, even if we do not understand it. This is the path of Muhammad sawas and the Family of Muhammad a.s. which is submission to the Hujjah after knowing him.

If you were living during the time of the Prophet of Allah Imran a.s, would you have disbelieved in him because he promised his people that a male child will be born to him, but then a girl was born to him?! Or you would have remained believing in him and certain that there must be a wisdom from Allah swt and a meaning of the Prophet’s words which you did not comprehend?

If you were living during the time of the Prophet of Allah Moses a.s, would you have been from the ones who worshipped the calf because Moses a.s had promised them to be absent for thirty days but he ended up being absent for forty days? Or you would have remained certain of his Prophethood and that he a.s is Hujjah, no matter what Shubhas (confusions) take place?!

If you were living during the time of The Messenger of Allah Muhammad sawas, would you have believed in the Isra’ and M’iraj (the Night journey) of Muhammad sawas, even if he sawas did not give you any proof that he sawas was taken from the Masjid AlHaram to the Masjid alAqsa and that he sawas ascended to the heavens?!

One last question: If you were living during the time of my leader and master the Messenger of Allah Muhammad sawas, and you were praying with him sawas FOR MORE THAN 10 YEARS in the direction of Baytul Maqdis…Then one day you woke up to find the Messenger of Allah sawas saying that the Qibla has been changed to the Holy Ka’ba instead of Baytul Maqdis…
Would you have been from the ones who immediately submitted to the Prophet sawas? Or you would have been from those who doubted in the Prophethood of the Prophet sawas saying if Muhammad was a true prophet he would have known the right Qibla from the beginning!

If you say that you would be from the ones who immediately submit to him sawas, then what made you submit? Isn’t the reason why you submit is that it is confirmed and proven with you that he sawas is the Messenger of Allah and that he is a Hujjah upon you from Allah swt?

As such is the matter of Imam Ahmed Alhassan a.s. and his door and vicegerent Aba al-Sadiq Abdullah Hashem a.s.
If it is proven with you that Imam Ahmed Alhassan a.s. is truly an Imam and that he is a Hujjah to whom obedience is obligatory and that he is the leader of the blessed Black Banners of the East, then whatever he a.s. says would be proven to you too without asking for a proof.

Rather, the proofs are given to prove the Imamate and the authority of the Imam or the Messenger, and it is actually your right to ask for proofs for his Imamate, and that’s what Imam Ahmed alHassan a.s. the leader of the Black Banners of the East has proven through the law of knowing the Hujjah which is stated in the Holy Qur’an, the glad tidings of the Messenger of Allah Muhammad sawas which none except him can give it, Istikharas and visions, Hadiths of Ahlul Bayt a.s. about The Black Banners of the East and its companion, the Hadith of Imam alSadiq a.s that we know the Qa’im a.s. through that he is the one who will reveal to us that family goes back to the soul world, the Ahlul Bayt’s a.s. hadiths that the banner of the Qa’im a.s. has on it “AlBay’a lilah”, Mubahala, challenge of the unseen, the oath of innocence, the guarantee of Imam alSadiq a.s. about the appearance of the Hujjah a.s. shortly after King Abdullah’s death, the testimony of the pure twelve men and the hadith about them, and and and and and and!! We have held tight to the Thaqalyn (the two weighty things; The Book of Allah and Ahlul Bayt a.s.) in proving that and all praises belong to Allah the Lord of the Worlds.

As for the proof for the knowledge he a.s. spreads, then this goes back to him a.s, it is up to him to bestow or withhold without account. Imam Zainul Abideen a.s said: “If we want to answer we will, and if we want to withhold we will withhold" - AlKafi v1 p211, and Imam alBaqir a.s. said: “This is up to us. If we want to answer you we will. And if we want to withhold the answer we will” . Then he a.s. recited the Qur’anic verse: “{This is our bestowal, so bestow or withhold, without account} ”. Source: Wasa’il Al-Shia V27 P66

Our test and the mission which Allah swt has charged us with is to find the Imam a.s. and know him and submit to him, not questioning his knowledge nor investigating with him!

Abu Ja’far a.s. said: “O Jabir, our saying is very difficult, extremely difficult, steady/firm, sharp/sagacious, rough, and pure/certain. By Allah, no one can handle it except for a Prophet Messenger, or a close Angel, or a believer whose been tested. So O Jabir, if something from our matter reaches you, and your heart leaned towards it, then thank Allah, and if you reject it then return it back to us Ahlul Bayt. AND DO NOT SAY HOW DID THIS COME, OR HOW DID THAT HAPPEN, OR HOW IS THIS POSSIBLE?! For by Allah this is the great Shirk (the great association) with Allah!” Source: Bihar Al-Anwar V2 P208

Abu Ja’far a.s. said: “O Salem, verily, the Imam is guiding and guided, Allah never makes him enter into blindness, and Allah never makes him ignorant of any Sunnah. IT IS NOT FOR THE PEOPLE TO INVESTIGATE ABOUT WHAT HE SAYS/DOES nor to be oppressive to him! RATHER THEY HAVE BEEN COMMANDED TO SUBMIT TO HIM” Source: Mukhtasar Basa’ir Al-Drajat:74

And he a.s. said: “Allah has charged the people with three things: Knowing the Imams a.s., submission to them a.s in everything that has come from them, and returning back to them in what they (the people) have disagreed about” .
Source: Mukhtasar Basa’ir Al-Darajat:74

Didn’t Ahlul Bayt a.s. say that the Qa’im a.s. demolishes what preceded him and starts Islam anew?
Didn’t Ahlul Bayt a.s say that the people only know 2 letters of knowledge and that the Qa’im a.s. is the one who will spread the rest of the 25 letters and add the two letters to them?
Didn’t Ahlul Bayt a.s. say that the Qa’im a.s. comes with a new matter which will be difficult upon the Arabs?

By Allah, it is difficult except for those whom Allah swt has guided.

{The foolish among the people will say, "What has turned them away from their Qiblah, which they used to face?" Say, "To Allah belongs the east and the west. He guides whom He wills to a straight path." * And thus we have made you a middle/fair nation that you will be witnesses over the people, and the Messenger will be a witness over you. And We did not make the Qiblah which you used to face except that We may make evident who would follow the Messenger from who would turn back on his heels.
And indeed, it is difficult except for those whom Allah has guided. And never would Allah have caused your faith to be lost. Indeed Allah is, to the people, Kind and Merciful.} [Holy Qur’an 2:142-143]

By Lady Norhan.
Y- Yamani et Yawmiates (Mémoires).

Salam, Le récipiendaire. Y-13. Il est aussi[…]

N- Nostradamus.

Salam, Au détriment des associateurs. N-7. […]